What's new
Photoshop Gurus Forum

Welcome to Photoshop Gurus forum. Register a free account today to become a member! It's completely free. Once signed in, you'll enjoy an ad-free experience and be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Wham am i doing wrong


johnsilvia

Well-Known Member
Messages
69
Likes
0
Hey guys, i have a problem that i dont know how to define.
im a beginner kids photography and somehow the picture come out fake after i edit them
i would really appreciate if you can dowkand the psd file and point out what i am doing wrong that the picture look fake (like no sense of depth of field)

thank you for all yur help

https://www.dropbox.com/s/yfgj085ozd96c1d/_DSC0516.psd
 
Best if you post it john in lieu of the link.
It does not look like a fake to me but it is rather drab. One thing I see is that your composition should comply to the Rule of Thirds. (look it up if you don't know what I mean) The lack of anything at all in the background does not lend itself to much depth. I'm not an expert by any means but if it were me, I might consider adding a background then blur it to give it some depth. Your colors need some pop also. Why not shoot the photos your doing on location where you have at least some color in your background.
 
Last edited:
I believe you've had several posts with the same basic question.

For starters you shouldn't be using the term depth of field.
Depth of field refers to what in your photograph is in focus in front of and behind the point of focus.
That's an in-the-camera adjustment.

What you're concerned about is the lack of depth between your subjects and the background in the image.
When using seamless backgrounds many photographers would be happy with the result you got.

If you're the photographer here you should be looking for a lighting setup adjustment, not a Photoshop fix.
I assume your using strobes with no modeling lights or you would see the result you would get.

You can try adding a very soft light behind the subjects, highlighting the backs of there heads.
That will create a space between the background and the subject.

There are a bunch of other things you can try but IMHO you have to fix the lighting when shooting the image, not look for a fix in PS after the fact.
Proper lighting when taking the photo is the answer to your situation.

With that said, are you stuck with these images as they are and can't re-shoot?
 
Well, thank you all for the feedback. As I said earlier, I don't have a direction of what am I doing wrong any be hearing your feedback it really gives me a lead to the right way.

yes I'm kinda of stuck with this pic need to deliver by the weekend
 
There are a couple of ways to create a realistic shadow, this is the one I like.
I have to assume you have a good working knowledge of PS.

Make a selection of the people using whatever method you're comfortable with, lasso, quick selection, magic wand, etc. it doesn't have to be perfect.

Use Refine Edge, smooth a little, feather a little, and shift edge in a little, set output to New Layer and hit enter.
If you have an old version of PS you may not have Refine Edge, in that case just use Ctrl+J (Cmd+J on a mac) to put the selection on a new layer.

Now duplicate the layer again.
What you should have now is 3 layers, the top two are just the people with no background, the bottom layer is the original with the background.

Turn off the top layer.
Select the middle layer
Hold down the "Alt" key (Opt on the Mac) and at the bottom of the layers pallet select "Create a new fill or adjustment layer" and select Levels.

Drag the left slider to the right and the image should turn black.
In that center layer paint black any areas that didn't go black

That's your shadow, rename the layer shadow.
Turn on all the layers and select the shadow layer.

Use opacity, Gaussian blur, and transform to get the look you want.

There will be areas of the shadow that you don't want, you can just erase those areas but I strongly suggest you mask those areas instead.
That way you can get it back if you change your mind.

With that shadow layer you can create soft subtle shadows, long harsh shadows, or anything in between.
soft.jpg

I know you don't want anything like the second image, it's just an example using the same layer differently.

Long.jpg
 
Steve- You da man! This will be a life saver for the OP.
 

Back
Top