What's new
Photoshop Gurus Forum

Welcome to Photoshop Gurus forum. Register a free account today to become a member! It's completely free. Once signed in, you'll enjoy an ad-free experience and be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Portrait Retouching... Suggestions?


danielhv

Active Member
Messages
38
Likes
8
I have a picture that I'd like to have developed... I have made a few subtle changes, however I'm not really sure I'm satisfied with it just yet. It was taken with the flash, which was a mistake as now I have a shadow that I don't care for, but it is what it is at this point.

Just not sure what direction to go here... Would have posted the PSD file but its 189MB. :(

Before:

aidenbefore.jpg

After:

aidenafter.jpg
 
That background is a real distraction and the shadow isn't a problem.
Clone out the shadow and blur and darken the background, or change the background entirely.

I didn't do anything with the boy just the background.
after.jpg
 
That background is a real distraction and the shadow isn't a problem.
Clone out the shadow and blur and darken the background, or change the background entirely.

I didn't do anything with the boy just the background.
View attachment 23319

Very nice. How did you get to that point? Been trying to figure this stuff out most of the day!

Sent from my Nexus 7 using Tapatalk 2
 
I'm sure Steve has a more in-depth explanation for you but what I see and as he said he didn't touch the boy what he did is use some sort of selection tool (pen or lasso) and put the boy on a different layer then he darkened the background using the levels or curves (Image/adjustments/curves or Image/adjustments/levels) oh and he took out the shadows out probably by using the stamp tool (he stamped over the shadows)
 
Nice shot. However, like everyone else, I agree that you've really got to get rid of that background. It is a major distraction for viewers' eyes, keeping them away from where they should be, ie, the subject.

Another, much less serious problem is that it looks like you used your 60D's built-in flash. This type of flash always creates a very stark look, exaggerating even features such as tiny bluish veins just below the skin that would normally be completely invisible, especially in a kid of this age (ie, with nearly perfect skin).

To illustrate how this portrait might look with a better background and lighting, I worked on it in Photoshop for a few minutes (result attached). Because of the very busy background, it is indeed difficult to make an accurate mask so that one can accurately modify only the background. It can be done (eg, with specialized masking tools), but, to be honest, I just didn't want to spend the time on this image. Instead, I simply made a rough selection, and blurred the edge of the subject as if the boundary between the subject and the background was slightly OOF. It's a cheat, but it's fast and not too bad.

I disagree with simply darkening the existing background. IMHO, that makes the photo look even more harsh and creates regions (such as the top of his head) where his hair would merge into a darkened background. Instead, I recommend a nice color gradient. It has sufficient visual interest, looks classy, but doesn't distract from the subject. Not withstanding the above suggestions and tweaks, doing the fixes (eg, background, lighting) in the real world instead of PS would produce vastly better results. See what you think.
Cheers,

Tom Maidenbefore-01_ps03a_698px_hi-01.jpg
 
Last edited:
i think steve did the best job on this one.
i see no problem with colorful background as long as it is blurred am dime so it won't drive attention of the main model, but if you remove it completely it will make it dull and passport alike-kind of photo.
main mistake taking this photo apart from the wrongfully used flash is that you placed boy very next to the wall.
if you made him stand just 50cm further from the wall-you will not have that hard shadowing around his head.
you may try duplicating the layer, then do the shaddow-hilight adjustment, and then partly erase overexposed parts of the photo.
your main problem is thick shadowing arround the chin.
be resonable with the autolevels that you did on your before-after editing as it just increased contrast between the face and hard shadows.
if you want to work more on it you may use the burn and dodge tool and play with the dark and overexposed parts of the photo based on its levels. you may slightly burn middle leveled tones arround the edges of the face to make it more round and realistic.
 
Ok, thanks for the tips everyone... I am fairly new to this, and realize I should have setup the shot better... That being said, what should have been done differently in your opinion? Background obviously, but what kind of background? Would a white wall be better? Or hang a dark sheet and use it as a backdrop, then replace the BG in PS? As far as lighting... should I use no flash at all and try to use ambient light to pickup all the details or should I get a different flash? Possible just diffuse the stock flip up flash?
 
A picture is worth a thousand words, Ibis. Show us what you would do.

Tom M

Ibis gave an opinion and instructions on how to re-shoot the shot with better results, and additional information on how the OP can improve the exiting image.
This forum is about helping each other not about I can do it better than you and I'll post an image to prove it.

I think you and I covered it all Tom.
Adjust the background or remove it.

All I did was clone out the shadows, duplicate the layer, create a selection, and created a mask.
Darkened the background with a curves adj layer, desaturated the background with a Hue/Sat adj layer and some gaussian blur.

I've removed the off topic comments.
 

Back
Top