Glossy button remake

[Aviorrok]

Hi,
I tried to remake a glossy button my button is the right and the original is the left button, how can I improve my button to looks more glossy


thanks!

 

[IamSam]

This looks great, you're just missing the hard edged highlights.

 

[Aviorrok]

This looks great, you're just missing the hard edged highlights.

View attachment 127216

I don't think it's the only things I missed LOL

 

[IamSam]

I don't think it's the only things I missed LOL

Possibly..........but it's a start!

Do you have a better image of the original?

 

[Aviorrok]

Possibly..........but it's a start!

Do you have a better image of the original?

No. Just a screenshot of a small icon from a website.

 

[IamSam]

I see. Without the original image icon vector image, it's hard to tell about any details.

Your re-creation looks fairly accurate. Once you have added the highlights, it will be close.

What do you think is wrong with your version?