What's new
Photoshop Gurus Forum

Welcome to Photoshop Gurus forum. Register a free account today to become a member! It's completely free. Once signed in, you'll enjoy an ad-free experience and be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Couple HDR -ish photos


hershy314

Guru
Messages
1,616
Likes
769
The first photo I only had one of I just duplicated it a couple times and using setting in HDR pro in Photoshop was able to change a few settings in each photo. The second was taken with my phone, all I did was change the ISO setting for each photo. I still have a lot of learning how to do this right but I think they came out ok. I do have a normal camera but It's a point and shot with dead batteries.

Untitled_HDR2.jpg35 Chrysler35chrysler.JPG
Untitled_HDR4.jpgIMG_20130403_223149.jpg
07 GT500 model I've been working on for the past 8 months
 
Last edited:
The main feature and the very name of the HDR technique is to allow a scene with a large range of brightness to be rendered with a reduced range of brightness. The before-after examples you posted do not illustrate this. For example in your examples, I presume the 1st and 3rd images are the "after" versions, and the 2nd and 4th images are the "before". However, the 1st and 3rd images have more, not less, contrast than the 2nd and 4th images. The changes I see could easily be accomplished with conventional manipulations of a single exposure and don't derive any of the benefit that a true HDR treatment provides.

Take a look at the example attached below (courtesy http://www.cambridgeincolour.com/tutorials/high-dynamic-range.htm ). This shows how two images, each with a range of brightness so large it can not be captured by a camera, can be combined into an image with a reduced range of brightness. If you want to derive the benefits of the HDR technique, this is the direction you should be trying to go in, not the opposite, ie, pumping *up* the contrast and saturation.

In addition, you mentioned changing the ISO on your phone to get a pair of images to be combined by the HDR technique. This is not the way to do it because, in most phones there is an automatic exposure system that will try to keep the exposure constant no matter how the scene brightness, ISO, etc. change. To make the HDR method work, you need at least two versions of the scene with significantly different exposures.

Finally, when you are taking multiple images you really need a means to prevent the camera from moving by even the slightest amount between exposures. Because of this, without a tripod mount, cell phones are almost impossible to use for HDR.

HTH, Tom

Tomunder-over-blended_in_HDR.jpg
 
Thanks for that, but I said it was HDR-ish not HDR only way I can get a true HDR photo is by using the right camera which I do not have currently.

I just read what was written, didn't have time. I didn't mess with the contrast or saturation except for a minor tweak. Using the HDR pro in PS CS6 I was able to change the exposure. I may not have changed it a lot. This was mearly a experiment type thing. I never said that these photos were real HDR ones. I do have some stock images that I could use for a true HDR look. I would like the right camera to do an HDR photos with. Just wish they didn't cost so much lol.
 
Last edited:
here are a couple of true HDR photos. Got the stock images from a tutorial by Brandon Bias of chchcheckit.com.
Untitled_HDR5.jpgUntitled_HDR7.jpg
 
BTW, the 2nd example that you cited, the house, shows a flaw common to HDR images from folks getting their feet wet in this area: - a halo around objects.

In most HDR tonemapping algorithms, there are usually one or two parameters which adjust blending and smoothing distance ranges. If you set these incorrectly, you wind up with a very artificial looking halo like this one.

T
 

Back
Top