Reply to thread

Yup, it's too bad we initially went down the wrong path, ie, a dramatic night look vs a spotlight-in-a-dark-room look, but so be it.

With respect to recreating that look, as Mike said, one can sort-of / kind-of fake it in post processing, but without any doubt whatsoever, it would be vastly easier, and the result will be of much higher quality if you just photograph your own band right from the start with the desired lighting.  (At least, I presume that's what you are doing, and you are not under contract to Iron Maiden to re-do their old photos, LOL.)

The problem with attempting to accurately simulate the spotlight look is that it's not just a matter of quickly darkening some large areas.  To make it believable, you would have to manually paint in new shadow and highlight areas on each of their faces, jackets, ... everything. Also notice that the light source in your 2nd sample image is from below, whereas the sunlight in the 1st version is coming from above.  Changing that sort of thing everywhere in the image is a big, tedious job even for someone who is used to doing it, and it's easy to get it wrong.

HTH,

Tom M